Monday, 25 April 2011

Fake IEEE Conferences. The MAFIA of IEEE is here



Fake IEEE Conferences. The MAFIA of IEEE is here
More Details

4 comments:

  1. This is to report to the research community that the SEDE-2011 conference (http://mavs.utdallas.edu/SEDE2011) accepted a fake paper:

    Name of Conference: SEDE-2011 20th International Conference on Software Engineering and Data Engineering
    Date: June 20-22, 2011
    Conference Web Site: http://mavs.utdallas.edu/SEDE2011
    Organizers: Narayan C. Debnath and Mary Ann Sullivan
    Conference Organization: International Society for Computers and their Applications (http://www.isca-hq.org)

    The SEDE-2011 conference claims that submissions/papers are reviewed/refereed BUT they are not properly reviewed/refereed.

    The fake paper was submitted for evaluation on https://cmt.research.microsoft.com/SEDE2011/ on February 7, 2011. The notification of acceptance was received on May 3, 2011.

    The following fake reviews of the fake paper were given to us on the conference submission Web site:

    Reviews For Paper Track Paper Submission
    Paper ID 17
    Title Tropist Method for Sequence Analysis

    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Masked Reviewer ID: Assigned_Reviewer_1
    Review:

    Question
    Research Problem Definition Neutral
    Knowledge of Related Literature Neutral
    Technical Content Neutral
    Language and Clarity Neutral
    Originality and Contribution Reject
    Overall Evaluation Accept as Short Paper (4 pages)
    Reviewer's Confidence Average
    Detailed Comments This paper has four contributions:

    1. They validate the internet QoS is game-theoretic, cacheable, and multimodal when using autonomous symmetries .
    2. A new client-server information(Tropist) is proposed to demonstrate that A* search can be made adaptive, probabilistic, and stable.
    3. They use extreme programming in the environment of IPV4 to achieve the purpose in 1, while IPV6 does not work well.
    4. They verified that while linked lists and kernels are continuously incompatible, IPV7 can be made interactive atomic and extensible.

    Cons:

    The paper lacks originality and no significantly technical contribution.

    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Masked Reviewer ID: Assigned_Reviewer_2
    Review:

    Question
    Research Problem Definition Neutral
    Knowledge of Related Literature Neutral
    Technical Content Neutral
    Language and Clarity Neutral
    Originality and Contribution Neutral
    Overall Evaluation Accept as Short Paper (4 pages)
    Reviewer's Confidence Average
    Detailed Comments This paper validates that Internet QoS can be made game-theoretic, cacheable, and multimodal.
    The authors prove that IPv6 and operating systems can interfere to answer this quandary and they use
    ambimorphic theory to verify that extreme programming and IPv4 can agree to achieve this purpose.
    They finally verified that while linked lists and kernels are continuously incompatible, IPv7 can be
    made interactive, atomic, and extensible.
    The algorithm they proposed can successfully investigate many information retrieval systems at once.

    However, each part of this paper has no clear relationship with others.


    THIS MESSAGE IS CONTINUED IN THE NEXT COMMENT . . . .

    ReplyDelete
  2. ANNA WORLD '11 - The 2011 World Congress & Expo in Chennai, India, accepted a fake paper. See http://annaworld.000space.com/ for further information.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree that several IEEE Conferences do not have review process at all

    ReplyDelete
  4. Another Collection of Fake (junk) conferences can be found in this site
    http://psrcentre.org/

    ReplyDelete